| More info | Plus d'info | Mais info | FishBase |
| No. | Valid Name | Author | English Name |
| 1. | Priapella bonita | (Meek, 1904) | Graceful priapella |
| 2. | Priapella chamulae | Schartl, Meyer & Wilde, 2006 | Sapphire toothcarp |
| 3. | Priapella compressa | Álvarez, 1948 | Palenque priapella |
| 4. | Priapella intermedia | Álvarez & Carranza, 1952 | Isthmian priapella |
| 5. | Priapella lacandonae | Meyer, Schories & Schartl, 2011 | Mizola toothcarp |
| 6. | Priapella olmecae | Meyer & Espinosa Pérez, 1990 | Olmec priapella |